At The Pet Carpenter, we know every dog is different when it comes to finding their perfect place to rest. Whether your dog loves curling up in a soft bed or prefers the comfort of a den-like crate, both options have their place. In this updated guide, we explore the benefits of each, how crate training supports your dog’s wellbeing, and introduce a design-led solution that blends the best of both worlds.
Why Choose a Dog Bed?
Dog beds are the more traditional choice, especially here in the UK. They come in all shapes and sizes — from soft cushions and mattresses to hard plastic or wicker baskets.
Easy to Move and Clean
Most dog beds are lightweight and portable, meaning your dog can always have the comfort of home wherever you go. Soft beds with removable covers make cleaning simple, while hard plastic options can be wiped down after muddy walks or puppy accidents.
When to Replace Your Dog’s Bed
While dog beds may seem the cheaper option initially, they do wear out faster. Over time, cushions lose shape, fabrics tear, and persistent chewers can quickly shorten a bed’s lifespan. When you consider how often they need replacing, the cost difference between a dog bed and a dog crate can even out over your dog’s lifetime.
Why Choose a Dog Crate?
Crates have long carried the misconception of being restrictive, but when introduced correctly, they provide a safe haven for dogs. A crate isn’t a cage, it’s a comfort zone that helps dogs feel secure.
In fact, research from the Generation Pup Longitudinal Study found that dogs given a designated safe space, such as a crate, are less likely to develop anxiety or separation-related behaviours. Crates offer calmness, structure and reassurance, especially for puppies or anxious dogs.
At The Pet Carpenter, we see every crate as an opportunity to design a calming, functional space that looks beautiful in your home. From fitted drawers to colour-matched finishes, our bespoke furniture combines your dog’s comfort with your lifestyle.
“We wanted something that would fit our home seamlessly and look beautiful too. The Pet Carpenter created a bespoke design that colour-matched our kitchen and gave Milo a space that’s both functional and stylish.” – Dinah, Reading
The Best of Both Worlds
Some dogs love the security of a crate, while others prefer the freedom of a bed. Many pet guardians, ourselves included, choose to offer both; giving dogs the freedom to rest where they feel most comfortable.
That’s why we’ve developed our open bedroom design, combining the open feel of a bed with the safe, enclosed structure of a crate. This design can also feature an optional up-and-over door, perfect for when you need to use the crate as a supportive training or safety tool.
👉 Learn more about this feature in our guide:
A Dog Crate Without a Door: How Up-and-Over Doors Provide Flexibility and Style
Each open bedroom is made bespoke, designed to blend seamlessly with your home while creating a safe, cosy retreat your dog can call their own.
FAQs on Dog Beds vs Dog Crates
Crates help puppies settle and develop positive routines. When introduced gently, they provide structure and security during the early stages of training.
Absolutely. Many dogs enjoy having multiple resting spots around the home, a soft bed for daytime naps and a crate for quiet time or sleeping overnight.
Add soft bedding, a cushion, or even a fitted curtain. The Pet Carpenter offers bespoke accessories like roll-down curtains for extra comfort.
Replace beds when they lose shape or support. The Pet Carpenter pet furniture is built to last for years, and accessories like bedding or cushions can easily be refreshed as needed.
Final Thoughts
Whether you prefer the classic comfort of a dog bed or the structure of a crate, the most important thing is offering your dog choice, comfort and safety. At The Pet Carpenter, we believe every dog deserves a space that feels like home, designed beautifully for both pet and owner.
Ready to Design Your Dog’s Perfect Bedroom?
Explore previous bespoke dog bedroom commissions and discover how we can create a space that’s stylish, practical and built to last.
For more dog friendly furniture and lifestyle inspiration, follow us on Instagram!
This article has been refreshed for 2026 with new expert insights from The Pet Carpenter team and findings from the Generation Pup study.